We’ve all been there. Planned an incredible lesson and been so excited about how wonderfully it is all going to unfold. Only to have the lesson flop. The students just weren’t as excited as we thought they would be. They didn’t seem to get the explanations that you thought were so clear.
It is after lessons like this that we really need to reflect on what happened and why. But often this reflection occurs in private, or perhaps during a debrief with a colleague. Almost certainly only with adults. What if we asked the students? What if they told us what went wrong and their theories on why? What if they told us what excites them and what doesn’t?
The idea of student feedback has been playing on my mind over the past few weeks as I have participated in Pernille Ripp’s online book club and as the teachers gathered at school before the students returned. Sure, we do a once, perhaps twice, yearly student survey. But what if we were checking in with students on a more frequent basis? What if students were providing us with feedback on a weekly basis? How might we structure this so feedback becomes a seamless part of the classroom culture? So, for Term 1, I’m going to experiment with a weekly feedback form through the platform, Socrative. Anonymously, students can provide responses to several short questions that will remain the same for the term. I don’t want it to be an arduous process; but rather an integrated part of our class culture; just something that we do. The questions I’ve decided upon are:
- List three words that best describe our classroom this week.
- What is something you enjoyed about our classroom this week?
- What is some thing you didn’t enjoy about our classroom this week? What could we do differently?
- Give Miss Davidson ‘Two Stars and a Wish’ – two things she does well and something you’d like her to work on.
I tried this for the first time on Friday, after a week at school, and the results were interesting, albeit relatively unsurprising, which I suppose it the goal of something like this (after all, when we hand a parent a report card, we know we haven’t done our job if they get a surprise at the results). I jotted down the common ‘least enjoyed’ experiences and have begun making plans to improve these – differentiating our morning puzzles and discussing/exploring how we can support students who feel the need to call out and interrupt all the time.
Another question that I want to ask my students on a regular basis this year is ‘What do you want me to notice about you?’ I did this several times last year and the feedback was incredibly interesting.
- I want you to notice that I always try my hardest.
- I want you to know that I find it hard to listen sometimes.
- I want you to know that I don’t understand Maths very well.
- I want you to know that the classroom is sometimes too noisy for me to concentrate.
This year, I plan to weave this question into our newly established Reflection Journal.
What questions would you ask your students to gather feedback on your teaching?